How to use Social Proof Messaging + Bonus Psychology Tactics

Social proof messages have shown incredible results when it comes to brand building and boosting sales for e-commerce sites. Why does social proof work so well? We break down the psychological process behind its success, so you know exactly how to implement social proof on your site to its greatest effect.

First, let’s look at the needs of our consumers:

  1. The desire for reliable information – Consumers seek information about product credibility, quality, and its unique strengths over competitor brands to make purchasing decisions.
  2. The desire to build an identity – Consumers buy into a brand because the products they carry form their personal identity. Convince consumers that your brand is what they want to associate their identity with.
  3. The desire to fit in and be accepted – Consumers conform with their peers and community, choosing brands that are socially approved.

These three main needs exist in all consumers, although to varying degrees. Understanding your consumer’s immediate needs, and matching it to your product will determine the ideal social proof messages for your business.

Social Proof for Information

When? For products and services that are novel or with novel features; unfamiliar and young brands; electronic and functional products.

What to use?

#1. Expert Social Proof

Top Strategies: Display certifications, badges, and trust seals near your products.


#2: Peer Social Proof

Top strategies: Reviews and ratings, testimonials

Taken from:

Bonus: Use Anecdotes

Go beyond generic reviews, and feature customer recounts. Think a heartwarming story about your product as a gift for their loved ones. Think a successful proposal with your product as the centre. Online browsing can be impersonal at times. Evoking emotions with personal stories both gains the trust and the attention of your online customer, encouraging them to buy into your brand’s legitimacy.

Social Proof for Identity

When? Best for for brand-building, in industries with strong competitor branding, especially for fashion e-commerce  

What to use?

#1: Peer Social Proof

Top Strategy: social connections


Taken from:

#2: Celebrity social proof

Top Strategy: Celebrity social shares

Bonus: Use with Personal Significance for Customer

Customers seek your brand because they relate to its story and image. Enhance this effect by personally addressing your consumer with messages. Use buzzwords like “You”, “We”, “Your”, and remind them of the image they would embody when subscribing to your brand. This tactic not only attracts buyers, but creates brand loyalty.

Social Proof for Conformity

When? For products and services with strong competitor brands, brands with big consumer base, good for fashion industries

What to use?

#1: Social Proof of Numbers

Top Strategy: Social Shares & Counts


#2: Peer social proof

Top Strategy: Social Shares

Bonus: Use with Status Quo Bias

Customers who seek social acceptance and conformity tend to avoid risk-taking and socially deviant behavior. Reassure them that their purchase is the norm. A nifty trick would be to make their purchase seem like an action to keep the status quo. Instead of “Brighten up your skin”, try “Keep your skin bright and clear” instead.
Remember – these tactics work for specific consumers. Using them generically for your customer base will be a blunt tool. Target these strategies accurately to the intended consumer type, for maximum effect.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s